Bethel Bakery Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing Bethel Bakery, a family-owned bakery known for their quality and delicious treats in Bethel Park, PA. Offering a delightful array of baked goods, including custom cakes, pastries, donuts, and more, they cater to all needs, even offering gluten-free options. Customers rave about their expertly crafted cakes, like the chocolate flavor and burnt almond torte, as well as their unique offerings like King Cakes and hot dog cakes. The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and convenient online ordering make it a standout choice for indulging in sweet treats. Bethel Bakery also specializes in wedding cakes, with a staff ready to make your cake dreams come true. Whether you have a sweet tooth or are celebrating a special occasion, Bethel Bakery is a must-visit destination for top-notch baked goods.

Gormet Pies Novelty Cakes Cookies Bread & Rolls Jumbo Muffins Breakfast Rolls Coffee Cakes

Gormet Pies

Upside Down Caramel Apple Pie

baked to a golden brown, our delicious apple pie is turned upsie down to let the sweetness of honey enrobe it. the finishing touch of creamy caramel & pecans on top make this pie a holiday favorite!
$18.45

Apple Half Pie
$6.45

Half Pie
$7.25

Apple Pie
$10.90

Apple Walnut Pie
$16.45

Teapot

serves , -inch triple layer cake.
$98.50

Lego Cake - Small

serves
$38.50

Lego Cake - Large

serves -
$56.50

Hoagie & Chips

serves
$73.50

Poppyseed Bagel

serves , -inch cake iced with buttercream & topped with real poppyseeds.
$54.25

Novelty Cakes

Cookies

Candy Corn Cookies

iced shortbread.
$2.50

Pumpkin Shortbread Cookies
$4.50

Half-Dipped Shortbread Pumpkins
$5.00

Jimmy Shortbread Daisy
$4.00

Chocolate Button

button colors change seasonally.
$5.00

Bethel Bakery Pepperoni Rolls
$3.37

Marble

by breadworks. whole loaf.
$4.30

Whole Wheat

by breadworks. whole loaf.
$4.30

White Pullman

by breadworks. this square white bread is perfect size for sandwiches and the toaster. whole loaf.
$3.89

Rye

by breadworks. whole loaf.
$4.30

Bread & Rolls

Jumbo Muffins Breakfast Rolls

Jumbo Muffins
$1.45

Apricot Cups

our delicious apricot filling is layered to sweet dough and formed like a cupcake. fondant icing tops off this breakfast treat.
$1.10

Fruit Danish

our rich and flaky danish dough is used to make these rolls. the oval shape allows a generous amount of apple, apricot, cheese, blueberry, cherry or pineapple filling in every bite.
$1.39

Nut Rolls

a single size version of our nut ring coffeecake, a generous amount of nut filling is layered into our sweet dough.
$1.10

Pecan Roll

great anytime of the day! this large sized breakfast roll has our moist cinnamon filling in sweet dough. topped off with whole pecans & honey glaze makes this great alone or warmed with butter.
$2.25

Hot Cross Buns

traditional sweet dough with raisins and glazed cherries. topped with a tasty icing cross.
$5.49

Cinnamon Danish Cluster

an old fashioned cinnamon coffeecake made of danish dough, a moist cinnamon filling and topped with crunchy cinnamon sugar.
$6.95

Danish Tea Ring

a coffeecake made of our delicious rich and flaky danish dough and topped with our fondant icing. a danish?s purist delight.
$6.95

Edelweiss

a popular danish coffeecake with custard baked in for extra moistness. chopped pecans and sugar are added on top for a mouth-watering combination suitable anytime.
$6.95

Fruit Twirls

a danish coffeecake with an apricot or cherry filling swirled so you have both danish dough and filling in every bite!!
$6.95

Coffee Cakes